Alice Flagg was young woman, and the brother of Dr. Allard Flagg; the man famous for owning “The Hermitage” which at the time was a large rice plantation. After moving onto the land in 1849, Allard invited his widowed mother and 16-year-old sister, Alice, to live with him. Alice Flagg was a beautiful young girl with long hair and bright blue eyes.

While performing errands in town Alice met a handsome young man with whom she fell deeply in love with. The two began to date. One day the young man came to visit Alice at her home when he was met by Allard on the front porch. After speaking with the man for some time Dr. Flagg realized the man’s low social status and qualities and sent him away before he could speak with Alice.

Outraged by her brother’s treatment of her beau, Alice agreed to meet the man in secret and they soon became engaged. One day Dr. Flagg saw a ring on Alice’s finger. He scolded Alice and demanded she return it. Alice agreed but instead tied it around he neck with some string.

In an effort to keep the two apart, Alice was sent away to boarding school in Charleston. She never forgot her lover and as such never removed the ring. She stayed at the school for months. One evening however, Alice fell ill with what was believed to be malaria. Because her brother was a doctor, he demanded that she be brought home and put into his care. By the time Dr. Flagg had gotten to her, Alice had gotten much worse. Dr. Flagg rushed to get her home, but Alice slowly fell victim to the illness. By morning Alice could no longer fight and silently died. Upon preparing her body to be buried, Dr. Flagg discovered the ring around her neck. He snapped the ring off and threw it out into the marsh. Alice was then buried at All Saints Cemetery near Pawley’s Island. A plain marble slab covers her grave. The engraving on the stone consists of only one word – Alice.

It is said that late at night, visitors can see Alice walking around the graves in a long white dress. To those a little more daring, they must circle the grave 13 times and place a coin on the stone before she “visits”. Other claim that she will only appear to true lovers who together place a flower or ring on the headstone. Our readers have sent messages around the legend telling us of strange noises, smells and even levitating rings that have haunted the people of South Carolina.

Sort By

unknown

Scare Score

Alice is not buried there in all saints like everyone thinks I’m a local of Murrells inlet and I know exactly where she is buried
2 years ago
Christine Vernon- Inlet Walking Tour

Scare Score

I perform the local ghost/history tour. There are different stories as to where Alice haunts. Unfortunately, she is not buried in All Saint’s Cemetery but in Belin Cemetery in Murrells Inlet. The stone in All Saint’s is a memorial. There have been about 4 or 5 Alice Flaggs that have lived here. Her grave in Belin is unmarked. Many believe it had been washed away during heavy floods. She haunts the Hermitage, and some say the marsh behind where her home once stood. Others still believe she haunts All Saints too. Some say she died of malaria, but her date of death is in January, no mosquitoes that time of year. I am currently researching and writing a book about her and other legends of the South Strand.
3 years ago
Anonymous

Scare Score

I have seen her but on the beach and in the surf of Garden City. This is where a saw a pretty young girl dressed in an old fashion white gown trotted into the water and disappeared.
4 years ago
Jane

Scare Score

It’s not really scary ,more like a peaceful place. They have really cared for their graveyard. Alice grave had trinkets on it but nothing out of the way. Really enjoyed walking through looking at all the older graves. History, history here
Their new church across the road was beautiful. Would go ahain. Thanks for the experience.
5 years ago
Anonymous

Scare Score

The legend is pretty creepy on its own. I’m sure that Alice is not happy about all the trash that has collected on and around her final resting spot.
6 years ago

Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Try To Scare Me

Haunted Places, Legends and Ghosts

Alice Flagg : Pawleys Island, SC

Alice Flagg : Pawleys Island, SC

Login